Op-ed by equestrian master and former national team coach Martin Plewa on the proposed LPO reforms

Martin Plewa on the Equipment Working Group’s Proposals for the LPO 2027

Opinion 12.11.2026
Martin Plewa. Photo: Lafrentz Martin Plewa. Photo: Lafrentz
Martin Plewa is one of today’s most distinguished trainers; he himself enjoyed success in eventing at the championship level, won a gold medal at the 1988 Olympic Games as the national coach of the German eventing team, later turned the Westphalian Riding and Driving School in Münster into one of the best training centers in the country, and in 2024 was honored by the DOKR with the title “Trainer of the Year – Lifetime Achievement Category.” He is a co-author of the guidelines for riding and driving. In a guest commentary for EQUI PAGES, he comments on the proposals from the Equipment Working Group for the 2027 amendment to the LPO.

I was deeply shocked to learn of the results from the Equipment Working Group, particularly regarding the recommendations for bits and equipment in the entry-level categories. Instead of significant expansions, I had hoped for the elimination of the approval of three-ring bits and Pelhams for the lower classes—and especially for the basic-level competitions, which are specifically intended to assess the quality of basic training (see guidelines).


The training of horses and riders up to and including Class L is described in the guidelines in Volume 1. The two bits mentioned are not mentioned there—and for good reason: The three-ring bit prevents correct contact because, with a constant connection, horses always tend to move “against or over the rein,” which also makes back engagement impossible.


In general, it must be taken into account that when a horse raises its head in response to the bit, this should always be interpreted as a defensive reaction to anticipated or actual pain. Finally, it should be noted that the horse’s tongue is, after the brain, the organ most densely innervated and thus one of the horse’s most pain-sensitive organs. In Rudolf G. Binding’s riding manual, the horse’s mouth is referred to as a “sanctuary.”


In our riding philosophy, “contact” is defined as a constant, soft, and springy connection between the rider’s hand and the horse’s mouth—a connection that is not possible even with the Pelham bit, which is already permitted in Class A. Due to the short lever arms, the force-multiplying effect of the levers is already at work even with normal rein contact; moreover, with broken Pelham bits, the lever force is even slightly stronger than with a bar bit. And with such bits, Class A riders are already allowed to enter the course, and young horses are permitted to compete in show jumping or cross-country classes! What a contradiction to our principles of classical riding instruction!


The continued approval of certain bits sends a devastating message to riders and instructors: if you encounter a problem or challenge in training, you simply need to look for a different bit instead of questioning your own methods. This renders our guidelines obsolete. My instructors, who still taught according to the tried-and-true, time-honored principles—mostly based on the 1937 Riding Regulations—would turn in their graves if they learned of such a betrayal of our riding philosophy, which is, after all, an intangible cultural heritage.


Vocational training must be brought back to the forefront


Before and after World War II, Germany was the world’s leading equestrian nation. Many German instructors were invited to other countries to teach our methods, which, after all, form the basis of the FEI rules. To now argue, of all things, that certain bits are permitted internationally or in other countries turns the tables: We are no longer the pioneers and role models for proper riding, but instead accept deceptive training methods from other countries that lag far behind us in terms of performance. One need only look at competitions in other countries at the level of our Class A, where most riders cannot even sit the trot (see FEI Dressage Test CCI*, which corresponds to our Class A, in which the entire trot sequence may be ridden in a light trot).


It’s worth remembering that even after the war, all German riders continued to ride their horses in show jumping and cross-country on a plain, single-jointed snaffle bit—and usually without a martingale as well. This was also a matter of course for me with all the horses I trained across all disciplines. In more than 25 years of service with the Westphalia Regional Equestrian Association—first as a regional coach and later as a training center coach—none of the junior or young riders was allowed to show up for training with any bridle other than a plain snaffle bit.


Regarding the specific proposals



  • Double-jointed bits exert greater overall pressure on the tongue because they do not allow the tongue to move freely at the joints; allowing double-jointed bits with a “flat” center piece now increases the pressure extremely when the bit’s sharp edge comes into contact with the tongue (pressure and surface area are proportional to the square of each other); with a single-jointed bit, a cavity forms beneath the joint when the horse is in contact, which gives the horse more freedom of movement for the tongue and also makes lateral rein aids easier for the horse to understand, because it increases the pressure on the cheek pieces.

  • Baucher bit for dressage: Is the Working Group actually aware that even a broken Baucher bit acts like a bar? It is assumed that the bit sits more calmly in the horse’s mouth, but it is the rider’s hand that determines whether the bit sits calmly or restlessly; the same applies to the assumed reduced pressure on the corners of the mouth; it is also incorrect to claim that no pressure is placed on the neck; one need only imagine how the metal connection to the cheek piece moves when the reins are taken up; the positive experiences cited by trainers and riders are due to the more pronounced bar effect.

  • A “bar” in dressage as well: As already mentioned, even the Baucher bit acts like a bar; allowing additional bar bits in dressage undermines a central tenet of our riding philosophy: it makes diagonal aids impossible (this also applies to riding with a curb bit, although correct positioning or a restraining rein is only possible with a double-jointed snaffle).



    Regarding the working group’s arguments in favor:


    “even pressure distribution on the tongue and bit”: incorrect, because a bar bit acts only on the tongue (hence, when misused, the “blue tongue” is caused solely by the bar’s effect); “calm and stable position in the mouth”: see above under “rider’s hand”; “no nutcracker effect”: It has long been proven by concrete scientific studies that this effect hardly ever occurs with a correctly fitted snaffle bit; if it were truly that harmful, this argument would require us to do away with the snaffle bit altogether; “advantageous for smaller mouths”: there are also small split snaffle bits; or is this meant to be a recommendation for pony riders?


    “Standardization with other disciplines”: in jumping or cross-country, no specific position is required;


    “Permitted internationally”: see my arguments above;


    “is frequently asked”: Who were these people, and what was their background? Or were they perhaps manufacturers involved in the matter?


    “Rubber, leather, or plastic bits suitable for horses with metal sensitivities”: I consider this argument to be a pretext; presumably, there are now so many variations in metal alloys that it is possible to find one that the horse will accept; furthermore, bar bits made of different materials can have very different effects, depending in part on the manufacturing method.


  • Double-ring bit: Whether the rein aid (which one?) is more precise remains unproven; precise rein aids come primarily from a sensitive rider (in the sense of riding theory: “When a horse is ridden correctly, it practically takes the rein aids on its own”; quote from the guidelines).

  • New mouthpieces to be approved (coils and rings): The idea that they prevent the horse from “biting down” is pure fantasy: only the rider could prevent this, and as is well known, this problem occurs most frequently with bar bits because the tongue is squeezed so tightly that the horse can no longer move it as it wishes; A constant, gentle movement of the tongue is part of the horse’s natural behavior while in motion (which is why immobilizing a horse’s tongue is also a matter of animal welfare!); The claim that this is intended to stimulate chewing contradicts riding theory, which does not attribute chewing with a closed mouth to a specific bit, but rather describes it as an essential characteristic of suppleness in correct contact.

  • Three-Ring Bit Addendum: It is completely incomprehensible to me that this bit—which I find harmful—is now also permitted to be used with a chin strap, especially without any mention of the increased squeezing effect on the tongue and lower jaw (similar to a loose double bridle) and without any explanation of the correct way to fasten it (for a double bridle: the chin strap should appear slightly straight when the lower bar forms an angle of approximately 45° with the mouth opening).

  • Bitless bridling: Seriously, even the mechanical hackamore is supposed to be allowed in all show jumping classes starting with Class A! I find this completely incomprehensible! On the one hand, we make an effort to ensure that nosebands are fastened correctly and in accordance with the guidelines, on the other hand, it will apparently be accepted as a matter of course in the future that, due to the considerable leverage involved, pressure many times greater may be exerted on the bridge of the nose and the lower jaw, thereby locking the lower jaw in place (is this relevant to animal welfare?).

    If a hackamore is used repeatedly (and presumably also during training), to the best of my knowledge, periosteitis develops, leading to subsequent ossification, which is visually evident as bulges that can be quite pronounced in some cases. For this reason, thick fur pads are often applied to conceal these bony protrusions. The argument put forward by the AK is completely unfounded. From a trainer’s perspective, I also have significant safety concerns because it is virtually impossible to restore balance on a hackamore to a horse that is leaning on its forehand—that is, one that is not “in front of the rider,” as described as an important criterion in the guidelines for breaking in. Many A-level riders often can’t even do that with a snaffle bit!

  • Pump Bit: I doubt the claim that this bit is “softer” and that it doesn’t pinch the lips; in fact, the opposite is true, because when the reins are pulled back, the bit is pulled upward toward the lips.


Conclusion


A working group that so blatantly disregards the primacy of good, horse-centered training has, in my view, forfeited any professional authority. This raises the question for me of who was a member of this working group, as well as how the German Judges’ Association, the German Equestrian and Driving Federation, the Federal Association of Professional Riders, and the representative for training on the FN Executive Committee have been involved in this matter or have taken a position on it.


It is evident that significant lobbying interests have influenced developments in the area of bits and equipment, at the expense of the further development of our sport based on improved training. Training experts should determine the conditions under which the quality of training at competitions should be assessed.


The trend toward incorrect, non-compliant presentations of riders and horses at competitions began quite some time ago. My current opinion is also the result of a working group—composed exclusively of trainers—that met several years ago and called for allowing only those bits listed in Volume 1 of the guidelines to be used in show jumping up to Class L. Show jumping lobbyists overturned this decision at the time in the Sports Committee. The approval of the sport protection girth is also unjustifiable; here, too, lobbyists pushed this through at the national level by citing “international” practice.


I have already publicly expressed my opinion on several occasions that it was a major mistake to abolish the Training Committee and leave it solely to the FN’s full-time staff to determine the rules for competitive sports. This is not a criticism of the full-time staff; however, the decision-making process shows that they are often subject to considerable pressure “from outside.”


I would like to point out that, in this day and age, we must make horse welfare our top priority. Any rule changes must be considered primarily from this perspective.


Martin Plewa


WP Wehrmann Publishing